Blog / Real Estate Law

Does a cigarette smell justify retaining a security deposit?

Landlords often have restrictive clauses in their leases limiting what their tenants can do at a property. Frequently, prohibitions on smoking in the unit are part of the lease. Landlords will tell current and prospective tenants that they cannot smoke cigarettes, pipes or cigars in the unit.

Unfortunately, with cold New York weather, always going outside to smoke may seem like a hardship for those quite dependent on nicotine. They may use inclement weather as a mental excuse for knowingly violating the lease and smoking inside. Others may think that they have a system that will prevent the landlord from knowing they smoke inside, such as only smoking in the bathroom with the vent fan running.

Can a landlord keep the security deposit of a tenant who smokes inside a unit during their lease?

Tobacco smoke can cause expensive property damage

Tobacco smoke is problematic for multiple reasons, with one of the biggest being how it makes an apartment look dirty. Walls, ceilings and even light fixtures may look dingy and dirty. Deep cleaning, repainting or replacing parts of the unit will likely be necessary to make it look clean again after a smoker has lived there.

Perhaps more concerning is the lingering smell of tobacco smoke. Especially in a unit with carpeting, the smell may be so pervasive that a landlord must make drastic interior changes to remove it. The costs of remediating smoke damage could be far more than the security deposit a tenant paid before moving into a unit.

There are specific rules for security deposit claims related to damage

New York landlords who intend to hold their tenants responsible for smoke damage to their properties will need to carefully comply with state law. Their obligations will include providing written notice to the tenant after they have left the property regarding the damage to the unit and the estimated costs to repair the smoke damage.

The landlord must give the tenant an opportunity to respond to their notice and substantiate their claims by providing evidence of damage or invoices from remediation professionals. Particularly in cases where the lease has a clear rule against smoking, a tenant may have a hard time fighting back against security deposit claims related to smoke damage remediation.

Learning more about lease violations and how they might affect the security deposit for a unit can help both tenants and landlords dealing with a smoke damage dispute.

Posted in:

Related Posts

What can landlords do about a loud tenant?

When dealing with a loud tenant, it is important for a landlord to take appropriate action to address the issue promptly and effectively. Whether you have noticed the noise yourself or you have been notified of a problem via a noise complaint, there are certain considerations you’ll want to make as you move forward. Initial communication The first step is to communicate with the tenant and make them aware of the noise issue. Contact the tenant, ideally in writing for record-keeping purposes, explaining the complaints received from other tenants or neighbors regarding the noise. Clearly state the specific noise-related violations or disturbances that have occurred, and emphasize the importance of maintaining a peaceful and quiet living environment for everyone. During this communication, it is important to remain calm and respectful. Give the tenant an opportunity to explain or rectify the situation. Sometimes, tenants may not be aware that their behavior is causing a disturbance, and a polite conversation can help resolve the issue amicably. If the issue persists after the initial warning, you can escalate the response to the next step. Taking legal action If the initial warning and communication fail to resolve the noise issue, you may need to take legal action. Depending on the local laws and regulations, you may need to issue a formal written notice, such as a “Notice to Cure or Quit” or a “Notice to Cease and Desist.” This notice typically specifies the noise violations, sets a deadline for compliance and warns of potential consequences if the noise problem persists. If the tenant continues to be disruptive and fails to comply with the notice, you may need to pursue eviction proceedings. It is wise to follow the proper legal procedures and seek legal guidance, as compliance violations can compromise the strength of your position and violate a tenant’s rights.

Can a lease protect a landlord from tenant injury claims?

Residential leases serve as a crucial form of protection for landlords and the tenants that lease their properties. The terms outlined in a New York lease can determine when a landlord has the right to evict someone and what amenities a tenant can expect. However, sometimes, there can be illegal terms included in a residential lease that are not actually enforceable in civil court. Landlords may include certain terms in their leases that violate state law in the hopes of confusing their tenants about their rights or may fail to notice such clauses in their documents if they download boilerplate documents to serve as their lease forms. If a landlord includes a clause absolving themselves of liability for any injuries that their tenants or their visitors suffer on the premises, is such a clause enforceable? New York statute holds landlords responsible for negligence State law is quite clear that no provisions in a lease absolve a landlord of the requirement to maintain safe and appropriate facilities for their tenants. If someone gets hurt due to omissions or negligence, which might include failing to maintain the property appropriately, the landlord can still face civil lawsuits and insurance claims despite including a provision intended to absolve them of such responsibility in their lease. Anyone who provides housing to others must meet certain standards regarding the maintenance of the property to ensure the safety of the tenants and visitors. Those hurt due to inadequate maintenance may have grounds for an insurance claim or a civil lawsuit. Learning more about New York real estate laws can help landlords and tenants alike navigate a dispute.

Can a landlord ban overnight guests?

People who rent a residential dwelling usually expect to have limitations on what they can do. Many accept that they can’t make holes in the walls or be incredibly loud. Other limits might also be present. One question that tenants and landlords have a lot is whether the landlord can limit the occupancy in the dwelling. New York law has a hodge-podge of laws regarding these situations, so it’s best to find out how the law applies to a specific situation. Occupancy type matters Many of the laws for rentals in New York are based on a dwelling being the primary residence of the occupant. For example, it states that you can have an additional occupant in a dwelling as long as it’s your primary residence. This effectively prevents a landlord from enacting a ban on overnight guests unless the dwelling is something other than a primary residence. Rent and terms also matter One limit that’s present in the Multiple Dwelling Law is that rentals less than 30 days are prohibited unless the occupant of the dwelling is present. This means that a tenant can’t rent the property as an Airbnb if they’re going out of town for a few weeks. But, they would be allowed to have a friend remain in the home while they’re gone as long as the home is their primary residence. Making sure that you’re in compliance with New York laws is critical when you’re a landlord. Having a tenant take legal action against you can be costly and time-consuming. Working with someone familiar with these laws can help you to avoid issues.